?

Log in

Previous Entry | Next Entry

As the mother of an Asperger child

I want to talk around the edges of the events at Readercon. I've never attended; I've only -- until now -- heard good to great things about it.

But in the wake of the events that occurred there, I've seen a few comments that crop up from time to time - always as an excuse or a defense of harassment: It's Aspie behaviour. He probably doesn't know any better.

Ahem.

This is, imho, garbage.

It is true that Asperger/ASD children often parse social signals incorrectly. The biggest indicator of this is their ability to monologue with great enthusiasm about their current obsessions. They glow with that enthusiasm and frequently fail to notice the way the eyes of their audience slowly (or not so slowly) glaze. This is not always fun for people who don't share their interests. It is not, however, threatening. I believe that most women can easily tell the difference between harassment and boredom.

Failing to notice boredom, however, is not the same as failing to notice that they are harassing someone. In the case of Genevieve Valentine and Rene Walling, Ms. Valentine made perfectly clear that she did not want to interact with Mr. Walling - at all, in pretty much those words. That clarity? Would come through loud and clear to any Asperger child I've met. She told him in no uncertain terms not to touch her or talk to her.

There is no way that my ASD child would fail to note this. Period. If Ms. Valentine had been polite, cheerful, smiling -- and had avoided Mr. Walling by adroitly disappearing behind a wall of friends without a single harsh word, it's possible that an ASD person might not understand just how unwelcome he was. But she told Mr. Walling to leave her alone. She used those words.

My oldest is now nineteen. It is true that he fails to notice things like flirting or active female interest in him. He tends to treat all of the people he meets the same way, regardless of gender. This can change, depending on their interactions, but he doesn't cross the boundaries of "stranger" or "friend" easily - and he has to be lead. I am certain he didn't initially notice that his girlfriend was interested in him as more than a friend, because she was always friendly and cheerful to everyone. He would not consider himself in any way an exception.

When he was five years old, he didn't understand personal boundaries. When he was seven years old he did. He learned them more slowly than other children, it's true - but he is no longer a child, and he did learn.

At nineteen, he would never do what Mr. Walling did. He hates to see people pressured. If his girlfriend says No to something, and the person to whom she says No fails to respect that answer, he can be a bit biting when he explains what that single syllable word actually means to the person who clearly doesn't understand it the first few times. This pressuring behaviour is one of the few things that makes him angry. Because he is sensitive to the application of pressure. It's not something he applies to people he's never met and doesn't know.

I get a little bit tired of having Asperger's brought up as an excuse for harassment. It's not. My son is fully aware that he doesn't always parse or notice social signals - so he is at great pains to observe, to try to understand; he errs on the side of caution in interactions with strangers. If my son is uncertain about social cues - he asks. There is no pejorative, to his mind, in asking directly. Holding someone else responsible for the "wrongness" of his thoughts would never even occur to him.

I would never, ever, ascribe the behaviour Genevieve Valentine was subject to to Asperger's or ASD. And it pains me greatly when people who aren't familiar with Asperger's or ASD do so, as if they are somehow exhibiting a greater and necessary tolerance. They are not. They are muddying waters; they are (unintentionally) condescending; they are (unintentionally) diminishing. I know this is not their intent--but that's the spillover effect.

Asperger children are often more careful about boundary issues, not less.

Comments

(Anonymous)
May. 6th, 2013 04:30 pm (UTC)
п»ї2012 achievement of trials of Changsha of challenge of city of imperial crown cup_0-spun4

This year achievement involving studies of Changsha associated with concern regarding city of imperial crown pot
Beijing period on Might 5, trial offers associated with capital of scotland - [url=http://wholesalenikejordan.tumblr.com]wholesale jordan[/url] train station regarding Changsha associated with problem associated with top notch involving town of spare golf regarding Tiongkok of imperial top glass is at team regarding golfing regarding catalpa mountain pond to absolve today The coming year, huang Hao presented rubric mind handle for you to count Seventy one handle for you to get world-class, in hand additionally Several gamers market easily April percentage overall ultimate. It's cement end result beneath: This year Huang Guan Bei Cheng Shi Tiao Zhan Sai Chang Sha Zhan Cheng Ji Pai Ming Qiu Yuan Cheng Ji Ju Biao Zhun Gan Bei Zhu One Huang Hao 71-1 Jin Ji A couple of Fu Hong Tao 720 Jin Ji Several Hu Nan 731 Jin Ji Some Li Shao Long 731 Jin Ji Five Hu Xiong 742 Jin Ji Half a dozen Zheng Xiang 742 Bei Shua Several Ji Xing 742 Bei Shua Eight Xin Yue Han 764 Bei Shua Nine Liu Chu Yao 764 Bei Shua Ten Zhang Shen Bo 764 Bei Shua 12 Kamu Chun 764 A dozen Yao Yu Xiang 775 13 Zhong Peng Chi 775 18 Zhang Fei 786 20 Tang Rui 797 07 Dai Jian 797 Seventeen Shi Zhi Bin 797 Eighteen Wu Xiao Wei 808 19 Li Xiao Wei 808 Twenty Liu Jun 808 Twenty one Yang Hua Feng 819 22 Xiao She Chu 819 23 Zhang Ya Ming 819 24 Zhu Xiao Jing 819 Twenty-five Tang Hai Bing 8210 26 Peng Xiao Hu 8210 Twenty-seven Deng Di Xiang 8210 Twenty eight Liu Xing 8210 30 Huang Zhong Yun 8311 Thirty Ren Fu Tao 8311 31st Fu Jiang 8311 Thirty-two Peng Hai Liang 8412 33 Wu Yu Long 8412 Thirty-four Deng Tao 8412 30 Zhang Chi 8412 36 Chen Lin Feng 8412 37 Liao Xiao Fan 8614 Thirty eight Cao Dong 8614 22 Long Zhou 8614 Forty five Lu Hong Wen 8614 41 Zhang Han 8614 Forty two Zhou Ming De 8715 Forty three Xiong Mo Lin 8816 Forty four Liu Zhao Xiong 8917 Forty-five Liu Guo Hui 8917 Forty-six Brown Xin 8917 48 Wang Xiao Jing 8917 48 Ma Hai Jun 9018 49 Liu Zhong 9018 50 Chen Jie 9119 1951 Bronze Jun 9119 Fifty-two Hao Shuai 9220 Fifty three Ren Fei 9220 Fifty-four Yuan Yi Jun 9220 Fifty-five Chen Ying Xin 9220 Sixty Cao Jie 9220 Fifty seven Liu Zhan 9321 59 Shu Ka Ming 9321 Fifty nine Guan Kai 9422 60 Li Xiang 9422 61 Qiu Jian 9523 62 Zhang Jia Li 9523 63 Jiang Jin Xu 9624 Sixty four Hou Di Rui 9624 Sixty-five Liu Yong 9725 Sixty six Zhuo Xian Wei 9725 Sixty seven Chen Bei Hua 9725 Sixty eight Du Zhi Hui 9725 69 Shi Wen Chao 9725 75 Ling Jian Ming 9725 71 Hao Jun 9826 48 Hu Jia 9826 Seventy three The Hui Jun 9826 74 Yu Guo 9826 Seventy five Zhang Jun 9826 Seventy six Zhou Gong Hui 9826 Seventy seven Fu Jun An 9826 78 Zhou Bin 9927 79 Zhang Jun 9927 70 Wu Dong Ze 9927 Eighty one Xu Rong 9927 82 Hao Jing 10028 Eighty three Gu Yuan 10028 Eighty four Peng Yu Hui 10028 Eighty-five Liu Liang Shuai 10028 Eighty six Cao Biao 10028 Eighty seven Luo Jin Ping 10028 Eighty-eight Yao Jin Yuan 10129 Fifth 89 Enthusiast Gang 10129 90 Feng Ke 10230 91 Sun Ge 10331 92 Luo Qi 10432 93 Liao Gan Xiong 10432 94 Zhu Wei Ping 10432 Ninety five Xu Suo Hui 10432 96 Zhou Wen Hai 10533 Ninety seven Dong Feng 10533 98 Peng Xiao 10634 Ninety nine Zhong Chang Ping 10634 100 Jiang Wen 10634 Info Shi Cheng Wei 10735 102 Liu Zhong Jiang 10735 103 Lin Jie 10836 One hundred and four Luo Yi 11139 A hundred and five Wei Fang 11139 106 Huang Yan Qiu 12351 107 Dai Jian Ming 12351 One hundred and eight Lao Wen Wu 12452 109 Tu Hao RTD 110 Du Hua RTD One hundred and eleven Liu Bi RTD 112 Xu Ren Qing RTD 113 Wang Yong RTD 114 Huang Lin Feng RTD 115 Feng Rong Hua RTD 116 They Ping RTD 117 Du Jin Hua RTD 118 Wang Ming RTD 119 Jie Bo RTD One-hundred-twenty Dai Fei Long RTD 121 Xie Guang Hui RTD 122 Hu Jin Feng DQ 123 Li De DQ 124 Huang Jiang DQ
(duty changes: Freelee)